If you want to beat or fight your New York traffic ticket case (or any criminal case for that matter), the first thing you want to do is take a close look at the paperwork. In a traffic case, the paperwork generally consists of two documents, a Uniform Traffic Ticket or "UTT", (also called a Simplified Information) and a Supporting Deposition. Together, the UTT and Supporting Deposition form the Accusatory Instrument. Those two documents become married and if there is ground for a divorce, those documents become useless and the case is done.
I will use a story from a case I got yesterday to explain why Supporting Depositions and UTTs (the tickets), sometimes do not get along and why it matters.
A NYC number came up on my iphone as I was enjoying a lovely afternoon on my deck with my wife yesterday, a warm sunny Saturday here in Ballston Spa. Seeing as how I have a family to support I figured I should take the call. The client told me two things right off the bat. He was innocent and he has a Class A CDL (Commercial Driver License). Because a CDL is a valuable asset to protect he was very concerned about his driving record as he should be. He was ticketed for "failing to keep right" in violation of New York Vehicle and Traffic Law Section 1120(a). The client was difficult to understand because he had a very strong French accent, but I thought I understood him well enough to advise him about his case and he hired me. He faxed me his paperwork. (A UTT and a Supporting Deposition) I ran his record and the record wasn't very good. (That's a bummer in traffic cases because it means that getting a plea bargain will be difficult and I might have to try the case. And even though I love me a traffic ticket trial, it means much more work and no extra money unless my client is cool and understands. I charge a flat fee for traffic cases and if I have to try them, I don't charge for it.)
So my client is charged with "failing to keep right". If you read the statute, it basically says a driver shall always drive on the right side of the road with some exceptions. His UTT indicates he is charged with violating this law. The Supporting Deposition alleges he was involved in a motor vehicle accident. It doesn't say anything about observing my client, the driver, failing to keep his car on the right side of the road. Remember how I said the Supporting Deposition and UTT have to relate to each other? In this case they don't. The UTT says "failed to keep right" and the spouse says "involved in an accident". These two are not getting along. They do not agree. If the documents do not agree with each other, a lawyer can make a Motion to Dismiss and hopefully the judge will grant the motion.
The police do not always give a Supporting Deposition to you when they write your ticket. They don't have to give you one unless you ask for it. Most New York State Troopers and some municipal police give you a Supporting Deposition for any speeding case where radar is used, or a visual estimate was made. But for many other Vehicle and Traffic Law violations, they don't give you one. If you didn't get one, you should talk to a traffic lawyer before you ask for it. Sometimes there may be a good reason not to get one.
Do not attempt to try to use whatever you think you may have learned here in court. Talk to a NY traffic lawyer first. I'm not always right and you will may make matters worse if you try to represent yourself in court.
A blog about real life lawyering by Christian deFrancqueville, Esq. in the Saratoga, Albany, and Capital Region area of New York. This is my diary. The posts below contain my stories and opinions. Nothing you read here should be relied upon as legal advice. If you want advice, feel free to give me a call.
Showing posts with label Motion to Dismiss. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Motion to Dismiss. Show all posts
Sunday, May 15, 2011
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Success Stories 2008
Guilty client charged with two Class A Misdemeanors: Charges Dismissed
This client got very lucky. He was caught on tape stealing. This particular client had a lot to lose because he had just graduated from college with a very expensive advanced degree and a criminal conviction would have hampered his ability to get licensed in his profession. Other criminal defense lawyers I have talked since would have settled for a plea bargain to one Class A misdemeanor. I was able to get the charges dismissed via the ACOD (Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal) Statute. NY CPL 170.55. Granted, not every prosecutor would have been convinced to go for that deal, but I convinced the prosecutor the dismissal was required in the "furtherance of justice".
What the heck does "furtherance of justice mean"? NY CPL 170.40. is the statute that explains the meaning of those words and states that to prevent injustice the court must consider a laundry list of factors including among others "the history, character, and condition of the defendant" NY CPL 170.40 (1)(d) and "any exceptionally serious misconduct of law enforcement personnel..." NY CPL 170.40 (1)(c).
In this case I demonstrated to the prosecutor and the court that the smallest mark on my client's record could potentially ruin his career before it even began and that considering the sacrifices my client had made to achieve his advanced degree, the only just outcome was a dismissal. Of course my client had to perform 50 hours of community service as a condition of the dismissal. A small price to pay.
When it comes to first time offenders, the "furtherance of justice" criteria can be successfully employed to get really good deals. Here is another story:
Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance 7th Degree NY Penal Law 220.03. Charge Dismissed
This was one of my most interesting cases of 2008 because It gave me the opportunity to do some research and the courtroom experience was a bit unusual, yet very fun. Again, my client had a lot to lose were he to be convicted even of a violation because his career would be in jeopardy. (Under NY Penal Law, a violation is an offense, not a crime. This is a very important distinction for obvious reasons. NY Penal Law 10.00(6) defines a crime as a misdemeanor or felony.)
My client got busted with a very small amount of narcotics in a public place. He was in a line and "consented" to a search of his bag. I learned that there was direct coordination between law enforcement and the private security company conducting the searches and that some of the security company staff were off duty cops. Ordinarily, anyone can be legally searched upon entering private property or public property. And if the searcher discovers contraband, the searcher can "arrest" that person and turn them over to the police. However, the rules change when the searcher is a police officer or is otherwise affiliated with the Government. That is because the 4th amendment applies and the Government needs either probable cause or a warrant to search you. Because the searchers in this case were acting in concert with the police with the objective of busting people for drug possession, the searchers essentially became Government agents conducting warrantless searches without probable cause making the searches un-constitutional. Anyway, that was my theory and I referred to it as part of my motion to dismiss in the "furtherance of justice".
The day this case was scheduled for arraignment was a special day set aside by the court to hear cases specifically related to the event at which my client was busted. Some of the most prominent criminal defense lawyers in the area had clients who were busted at the event including one guy who is arguably the most prominent criminal defense attorney in Albany. I discussed my legal theory with him about the searches and he not surprisingly agreed with me but he, like me, had clients who hired us to get deals, not contest the charge.
When my turn with the Assistant District Attorney came up, the Judge happened to be present during the meeting. I used that opportunity to explain to both the People and the Court why the charge against my client should be dismissed under the ACOD statute. I was prepared with arguments that satisfied all the criteria of the "furtherance of justice" statute. At the end of my presentation the judge said he would accept the deal. The ADA said he would as well but we would have to adjourn the court date because he did not want all the other attorneys in the court room to hear that he gave me that deal.
I consider that case a win.
This client got very lucky. He was caught on tape stealing. This particular client had a lot to lose because he had just graduated from college with a very expensive advanced degree and a criminal conviction would have hampered his ability to get licensed in his profession. Other criminal defense lawyers I have talked since would have settled for a plea bargain to one Class A misdemeanor. I was able to get the charges dismissed via the ACOD (Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal) Statute. NY CPL 170.55. Granted, not every prosecutor would have been convinced to go for that deal, but I convinced the prosecutor the dismissal was required in the "furtherance of justice".
What the heck does "furtherance of justice mean"? NY CPL 170.40. is the statute that explains the meaning of those words and states that to prevent injustice the court must consider a laundry list of factors including among others "the history, character, and condition of the defendant" NY CPL 170.40 (1)(d) and "any exceptionally serious misconduct of law enforcement personnel..." NY CPL 170.40 (1)(c).
In this case I demonstrated to the prosecutor and the court that the smallest mark on my client's record could potentially ruin his career before it even began and that considering the sacrifices my client had made to achieve his advanced degree, the only just outcome was a dismissal. Of course my client had to perform 50 hours of community service as a condition of the dismissal. A small price to pay.
When it comes to first time offenders, the "furtherance of justice" criteria can be successfully employed to get really good deals. Here is another story:
Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance 7th Degree NY Penal Law 220.03. Charge Dismissed
This was one of my most interesting cases of 2008 because It gave me the opportunity to do some research and the courtroom experience was a bit unusual, yet very fun. Again, my client had a lot to lose were he to be convicted even of a violation because his career would be in jeopardy. (Under NY Penal Law, a violation is an offense, not a crime. This is a very important distinction for obvious reasons. NY Penal Law 10.00(6) defines a crime as a misdemeanor or felony.)
My client got busted with a very small amount of narcotics in a public place. He was in a line and "consented" to a search of his bag. I learned that there was direct coordination between law enforcement and the private security company conducting the searches and that some of the security company staff were off duty cops. Ordinarily, anyone can be legally searched upon entering private property or public property. And if the searcher discovers contraband, the searcher can "arrest" that person and turn them over to the police. However, the rules change when the searcher is a police officer or is otherwise affiliated with the Government. That is because the 4th amendment applies and the Government needs either probable cause or a warrant to search you. Because the searchers in this case were acting in concert with the police with the objective of busting people for drug possession, the searchers essentially became Government agents conducting warrantless searches without probable cause making the searches un-constitutional. Anyway, that was my theory and I referred to it as part of my motion to dismiss in the "furtherance of justice".
The day this case was scheduled for arraignment was a special day set aside by the court to hear cases specifically related to the event at which my client was busted. Some of the most prominent criminal defense lawyers in the area had clients who were busted at the event including one guy who is arguably the most prominent criminal defense attorney in Albany. I discussed my legal theory with him about the searches and he not surprisingly agreed with me but he, like me, had clients who hired us to get deals, not contest the charge.
When my turn with the Assistant District Attorney came up, the Judge happened to be present during the meeting. I used that opportunity to explain to both the People and the Court why the charge against my client should be dismissed under the ACOD statute. I was prepared with arguments that satisfied all the criteria of the "furtherance of justice" statute. At the end of my presentation the judge said he would accept the deal. The ADA said he would as well but we would have to adjourn the court date because he did not want all the other attorneys in the court room to hear that he gave me that deal.
I consider that case a win.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)