I was making small talk with another lawyer the other night. We were discussing the kind of work we do. She had clerked for the Court of Appeals (the highest court in NY) and now is employed by a very fancy law firm, where she is an associate in the medical malpractice department. In contrast, I worked as a carpenter nearly full time when I went to a law school and other than a stint for a firm, I have been a solo practitioner handling mostly traffic and DWI cases. I was feeling, well let's say a little low class, but we ended up having a lengthy and very interesting conversation.
At one point the lawyer told me about the one traffic case she handled and how she felt bad for the client because she could not get him a deal, and he paid a grand for the service. The client was a doctor who was ticketed for allegedly "failing to yield the right of way" resulting in a minor personal injury accident. The prosecutor offered to "reduce" the charge to a "failure to obey a traffic control device" or NY VTL 1110(A). The lawyer said she took the "deal" because if her client was convicted of the failure to yield right of way offense, the conviction would be offered as evidence against him at a personal injury trial. I'm still confused why this lawyer thought that a guilty plea to the 1110(a) charge would be any different. The 1110(a) is a moving violation that carries two points. In my opinion, this lawyer essentially pled her client guilty to the charge. In any case, if the offer is plead to the charge, there is no offer and you have nothing to lose by going to trial, and something to gain by the chance of winning the trial.
In the case of this doctor and the accident, the cop who wrote the ticket did not see the accident himself. Unless the cop is an accident reconstruction expert, he can't testify about something he did not see. The burden is on the people at trial to establish a prima facie case and without a witness testifying from personal knowledge, that will be tough. Maybe the people have witnesses who saw the accident. Well if it's the people in the other car, and they are there to testify, why not at least cross examine them? They are probably biased and have a motive to lie.
I believe there is a general notion that any attorney can handle a traffic case, and it is generally true that any moderately competent attorney can negotiate as decent plea bargain. However, it does not follow that such an attorney will have the skills to actually defend a traffic defendant. That is because a real traffic attorney is a trial lawyer first. There are traffic lawyers who are excellent deal makers but when the chips are down, they will plead a client guilty to the charge because they do not know how to fight.
A blog about real life lawyering by Christian deFrancqueville, Esq. in the Saratoga, Albany, and Capital Region area of New York. This is my diary. The posts below contain my stories and opinions. Nothing you read here should be relied upon as legal advice. If you want advice, feel free to give me a call.
Showing posts with label trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trial. Show all posts
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Wednesday, November 5, 2008
Beat Your Ticket? Good luck.
I recently won a speeding ticket trial. Ironically, I got the decision around the same time I was explaining to a prospective client why it is nearly impossible to beat a speeding ticket case. This guy was telling me the typical story; He wasn't doing 88, hew was doing 81. There is no way the cop could have seen him over the hill. The car next to him was moving faster. There was a mistake in the paperwork. The cop was a jerk. Etc.
To all those who think they can beat their ticket listen up: Your story means nothing to the Court. The cop's story means everything. A lawyer I used to work with used to interrupt a client mid story and say "I understand what your are saying, but what is the cop going to say?"
Keep in mind, to beat your ticket you have to try your case and speeding ticket trials are easy for a prosecutor to win, at least in New York. Basically, they have to show one of two things; that the officer visually estimated the speed, or there was a reading from a radar or LIDAR (laser) device that was in working order at the time of the reading. Believe me, cops are generally prepared for trial and have done it a million times.
Back to my trial; I didn't fight the case because I had a good case. I fought the case because I couldn't get a good enough deal for my client and I had nothing to lose by fighting. How did I win? The cop testified that he did not do a visual estimate. He also testified that he used a LIDAR device to measure my client's speed. However, when asked if he had any documents showing the LIDAR had been recently calibrated, he answered no.
The prosecution argued that there is no case law saying a LIDAR device, (unlike a radar device), requires documentation that it has been recently tested for its reading to be admissible at trial. I argued that a LIDAR device is a machine like a radar gun, or breath testing device, or any other scientific instrument, which all require some proof of working order for their readings to be admissible at trial. In this case, the judge agreed with me and dismissed the case.
To all those who think they can beat their ticket listen up: Your story means nothing to the Court. The cop's story means everything. A lawyer I used to work with used to interrupt a client mid story and say "I understand what your are saying, but what is the cop going to say?"
Keep in mind, to beat your ticket you have to try your case and speeding ticket trials are easy for a prosecutor to win, at least in New York. Basically, they have to show one of two things; that the officer visually estimated the speed, or there was a reading from a radar or LIDAR (laser) device that was in working order at the time of the reading. Believe me, cops are generally prepared for trial and have done it a million times.
Back to my trial; I didn't fight the case because I had a good case. I fought the case because I couldn't get a good enough deal for my client and I had nothing to lose by fighting. How did I win? The cop testified that he did not do a visual estimate. He also testified that he used a LIDAR device to measure my client's speed. However, when asked if he had any documents showing the LIDAR had been recently calibrated, he answered no.
The prosecution argued that there is no case law saying a LIDAR device, (unlike a radar device), requires documentation that it has been recently tested for its reading to be admissible at trial. I argued that a LIDAR device is a machine like a radar gun, or breath testing device, or any other scientific instrument, which all require some proof of working order for their readings to be admissible at trial. In this case, the judge agreed with me and dismissed the case.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)